Skip to content 
Ah, the age-old debate: harnesses vs. collars. As a dog trainer extraordinaire, I’ve heard every argument in the book. But let’s sniff out the truth, shall we?
Harnesses can indeed be safer than collars for many dogs, especially those prone to pulling or with neck issues. How so? Well, harnesses distribute pressure more evenly across the body, reducing the risk of neck strain or injury.
Now, let me bark some more wisdom your way!
The Battle of the Collar and Harness
In the left corner, we have collars: the OG accessory for every doggo. And in the right corner, we have harnesses: the new kid on the block stealing hearts and leashes. Let’s size up their pros and cons before we crown a winner, shall we?
Collar Pros:
- Lightweight and simple design.
- Ideal for holding identification tags.
- Easy to slip on and off.
Collar Cons:
- Can cause neck strain or injury, especially for pullers.
- Limited control, particularly for strong or enthusiastic dogs.
- Not suitable for dogs with respiratory issues or delicate necks.
Harness Pros:
- Distributes pressure more evenly across the body.
- Offers better control, especially for pullers.
- Can be safer and more comfortable, particularly for dogs prone to neck injuries.
Harness Cons:
- Can be more complex to put on, especially for wriggly pups.
- Some dogs may resist wearing a harness initially.
- Not ideal for holding tags unless equipped with a D-ring.
But What About Training?
Ah, the million-dollar question! Can harnesses hinder training? Not necessarily. In fact, they can make it easier. Harnesses discourage pulling, teaching your pup proper leash manners from the get-go. And for those stubborn pullers, front-clip harnesses can work wonders. They redirect your pup’s attention back to you, making training sessions less of a tug-of-war.
The Comfort Factor
Let’s talk comfort. Would you rather wear a snug sweater or a tight choker necklace? I know my answer! Harnesses provide a snug yet comfortable fit, ensuring your furry friend can strut their stuff without feeling restricted. Plus, they come in all shapes, sizes, and styles, so your pup can express their unique fashion sense.
Tailoring to Your Pup’s Needs
Every dog is different, just like every human is unique. That’s why it’s essential to consider your pup’s individual needs when choosing between a harness and a collar. Do they have a history of neck injuries? Are they prone to pulling? Are they still in training mode? By understanding your pup’s quirks, you can make an informed decision that keeps them safe and happy.
Final Verdict: Safety First!
In the battle of harnesses vs. collars, safety should always be the top priority. While collars have their place, especially for holding identification tags, harnesses often come out on top when it comes to comfort, control, and injury prevention. So, next time you’re gearing up for a walk, consider strapping on a harness and giving your pup the gift of safety and style!
QQPETS is the leading wholesale dog harness manufacturer of adjustable harnesses for dogs and other items that people may use when walking their dogs. Our goal is to make dog walking easy for pet owners by providing valuable accessories. We offer a variety of customization services including custom logos, custom graphics, custom products and more. If you want to start your dog products business, check out our website and contact us today.
FAQ about dog collar and dog harness
1. Is it better to use a harness or collar?
The choice between using a harness or collar often depends on your dog’s needs, behavior, and health. Harnesses are generally better for dogs that pull, have respiratory issues, or are prone to injuries like tracheal collapse, as they distribute pressure more evenly around the body instead of the neck. Collars are suitable for dogs that do not pull and for conveniently carrying ID tags and registration.
2. Do vets recommend collars or harnesses?
Veterinarians typically recommend harnesses over collars, especially for dogs with neck or back problems, or those prone to respiratory issues. Harnesses are safer for controlling your dog without the risk of choking or straining the neck. However, for well-behaved dogs that do not have these issues, vets may consider collars acceptable.
3. Do dogs feel safer in a harness?
Many dogs do feel safer in a harness because it provides a sense of security without the discomfort that a collar can cause when pulling. Harnesses support the body more evenly and reduce stress on the neck and throat, which can make anxious or skittish dogs feel more secure during walks or in crowded places.
4. Is it better to run with a dog in a harness or collar?
For running, a harness is generally the better choice. It offers greater control and safety for both the dog and the handler. Running with a harness prevents the dog from choking or gagging when pulling ahead and makes it easier to manage sudden movements or pulling, which is especially important for high-energy activities like running.
In summary, harnesses tend to be the safer and more comfortable choice for most activities, especially for dogs that are prone to pulling or have certain health issues. They provide better control during physical activities and are more comfortable for the dog, promoting a safer and more enjoyable experience for both pet and owner.
