Skip to content 
Hello, fellow pet enthusiasts! Are you tangled up in the leash every time you walk your spirited pup? If so, you’re probably wrestling with this common dilemma: is a collar or a harness better for a dog that pulls? Let’s unravel this topic and steer you towards a walk that’s enjoyable for both you and your furry friend!
For dogs that pull, a harness is generally better than a collar. Harnesses distribute pressure more evenly across the dog’s body, reducing strain on the neck and providing better control during walks. Particularly, no-pull harnesses with front attachments are effective as they help manage and reduce pulling by redirecting the dog’s movement towards the owner when they try to pull forward. This setup is safer and more comfortable for the dog, and it aids in teaching better leash manners.
Getting to grips with your dog’s enthusiasm on walks can be challenging. Whether you opt for a collar or a harness can significantly influence your control and your dog’s comfort. Let’s dig into which option might be the best for your canine companion.
Understanding the Dynamics of Pulling
Before we jump into gear choices, it’s crucial to understand why dogs pull. Pulling is often a sign of excitement, lack of training, or simply the dog’s natural pace being faster than yours. Addressing the root cause through training is essential, regardless of the gear you choose.
The Case for Harnesses
Harnesses are widely recommended for dogs that pull because they distribute pressure more evenly around the dog’s body, preventing stress on the neck and throat. Especially for brachycephalic breeds (like pugs and bulldogs), which are prone to respiratory issues, a harness can prevent dangerous pressure on the airway.
Types of Harnesses for Pullers
- Front-clip harnesses: These attach at the chest and are effective at redirecting a dog’s direction back towards the owner, making it easier to regain their attention and correct pulling behavior.
- Dual-clip harnesses: Offering attachments on both the front and back, they provide versatility depending on the situation and training needs.
Each type has its pros and cons, but the key advantage is reducing strain on your dog’s neck and improving control during walks.
The Argument for Collars
Collars are a traditional choice and are suitable for dogs that don’t have issues with pulling or respiratory constraints. They are lightweight, easy to keep on for identification, and often less cumbersome for dogs to wear than harnesses.
However, for dogs that pull, collars can increase the risk of neck injuries, tracheal collapse, and in some cases, even spinal problems. Therefore, they are generally recommended for trained dogs who walk calmly.
Training to Minimize Pulling
Regardless of whether you choose a collar or a harness, training is key to reducing pulling. Positive reinforcement techniques, where dogs are rewarded for walking nicely without pulling, can be very effective. Training sessions that focus on leash manners are essential for a stress-free walking experience.
Comfort and Fit Matter
No matter the choice, ensuring the right fit is crucial to avoid discomfort or potential escape. A poorly fitting harness or collar can rub and chafe, or worse, allow your dog to slip out. Regular checks and adjustments should be part of your routine.
Personal Considerations and Dog Specifics
Finally, consider your dog’s specific behavior, size, and any health concerns. What works for one dog might not work for another. Consulting with a veterinarian or a dog trainer can provide personalized advice based on your dog’s health and temperament.
Conclusion
Choosing between a collar and a harness for a dog that pulls depends largely on your dog’s specific needs and behavior. While harnesses generally offer better safety and control for pullers, collars might be suitable for calm, well-trained dogs. Always prioritize your dog’s comfort and safety in your choice.
QQPETS is the leading custom dog harness manufacturer of adjustable harnesses for dogs and other items that people may use when walking their dogs. Our goal is to make dog walking easy for pet owners by providing valuable accessories. We offer a variety of customization services including custom logos, custom patterns, custom materials, custom sizes and custom products and more. If you want to start your dog products business, check out our website and contact us today.
FAQ about pulling
Is a collar or harness better for a dog that pulls? A harness is better for a dog that pulls. A no-pull harness, especially with a front leash attachment, is designed to reduce and manage pulling more effectively than a collar.
Do vets recommend collars or harnesses? Vets typically recommend harnesses over collars, particularly for dogs that pull or have respiratory or tracheal issues. Harnesses distribute pressure more safely and evenly around the body, avoiding the neck.
Do dogs pull more with a harness? Dogs may pull more with a standard back-attachment harness as it doesn’t discourage the behavior and allows them to use their body strength. However, front-attachment, no-pull harnesses can decrease pulling by redirecting the dog towards you when they pull.
Do collars help with pulling? Collars do not effectively help with pulling and can increase the risk of neck injury or discomfort. For dogs that pull, a no-pull harness is a safer and more effective choice.
